Showing posts with label Security Council 2015. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Security Council 2015. Show all posts

Press Conference

A press Conference was conducted by the International press of MUN. It brought to light everyone's views on the issue that had been discussed till that time. The delegates were asked to give a brief summary of the session.
Russia and Syria stated that the reason for the failure of this discussion was that the US and France were not cooperative and did not consult Syria about the decision.Syria further said that US had failed to recognize the willingness of Syrian Government to conduct elections,calling US a "self proclaimed' superpower.
US however countered that statement by saying that it wont participate with anyone involved with the Syrian Government. He claimed that the Security Council couldn't arrive to a conclusion because Russia showed support for Syria and decided to support it's ruler inspite of multiple human rights violations.
UK gave a moving statement saying how dismal and disappointing to see that no resolution was reached . He also stated that what happens in the world is a matter of global concern. He ended by saying that the discussions concerning this Syrian issue shouldn't end here.

The Final discussion

The delegates discussed on the two resolutions.This led to the resolution 1  being changed to 1.2, and the resolution 2 being changed to 2.4.
Resolution 1.2 failed as it was vetoed by China. Resolution 2.4 failed as it was vetoed by US.

Ultimately the Security Council was unable to reach a conclusion regarding the issue, and the committee was adjourned.



Two resolutions to be debated upon in the UNSC

In a recent un-moderated caucus, two resolutions were created and submitted to the executive board for discussion. The resolutions are given below.

Resolution 1

Sponsors – FRANCE, USA, UK
Signatories – Italy, Kuwait, Israel, Turkey, Iraq, Jordan, Germany, Lebanon, Egypt

Recalling its resolutions 2042 (2012), 2043 (2012), especially 2118 (2013), 2139 (2014), and its presidential statement of 2 October 2013,

Taking into consideration the unanimous support for Resolution 2139 (2014), but regretting the inability of the parties involved to comply with the demands of resolution 2139 (2014), as described in the Secretary-General's report S/2014/208 (2014),

Realizing the need to specify a timeline for the implementation of effective steps, in case of non-compliance with resolution 2139 (2014),

1. Calls for a Geneva III Conference that is an inclusive negotiation process between the Syrian government and Syrian opposition groups, such as the National Coalition of Syrian Revolution and Opposition Forces, to restore diplomatic dialogue between the parties, to be held from 1 November until 15 November 2015, consisting of two phases:

a. Phase I, where the parties present will focus only on the implementation of Resolution    2139 (2014) and ensuring the safe delivery of humanitarian aid, with emphasis on the    following issues: 
i. Increased frequency and duration of humanitarian pauses in order to provide relief   for the Syrian civilian population,
ii. Further reducing bureaucratic impediments to the delivery of humanitarian     assistance, such as the issuing of the required visa for aid workers,
iii. Increasing the number of entry points around the Syrian border,
iv. Allowing additional United Nations staff and other international observers into the    Syrian territory,

b. Phase II, focused on a political solution to this conflict, based on an update of the 2012    Geneva Communiqué, and which will be applied only when all parties to the conflict      reach a written agreement on the first phase;

2. Authorizes US and France led coalition to stay inside Syria if the Geneva III conference fails;

3. Urges all parties to the Syrian conflict to contribute to creating an environment conducive to productive negotiations to facilitate the Geneva III Peace Talks;

4. Calls upon the international community to facilitate the implementation of all aspects of resolution 2139 (2014), in particular paragraphs 2 through 12, within 90 days from the adoption of this resolution;

5. Expressing its commitment to take effective steps in the case of non-compliance with the aforementioned implementation of resolution 2139 (2014);

6. Invites the Syrian government and opposition groups to:
a. Provide increased access for aid agencies under the aegis of the United Nations Office of    the Coordination of Human Affairs (UNOCHA), to provide assistance to Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs) and civilians trapped in combat zones who are denied access to water,    food, non-food items and medicine,
b. Work with the United Nations and all relief agencies in possible future multilateral talks    between the Syrian government, opposition groups and the international community, to    ensure that aid workers are given the visa and travel requirements necessary for them to    continue their work in the region, 
c. Coordinate with UNOCHA to provide security to aid workers working in conflict zones   and IDP camps in Syria as well as their movement within country,
d. Open more border crossing points and decrease the number of internal checkpoints that    aid personnel are required to pass through, to ensure unhindered access to aforementioned zones in a timely manner;

7. Approves the reestablishment of the Informal Working Group on the Protection of Civilians in  Armed Conflict (Working Group) to be assembled on the issue of refugees and internally displaced persons affected by the Syrian Conflict;

8. Designates that the Working Group will:

a. Be comprised of, but not be limited to, Turkey, Lebanon, Jordan, Iraq, Egypt, Syria, the    Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) and the permanent members     of the Security Council, 

b. Collaborate with existing regional partners to provide best practices to IDP camps in Syria, focusing on the communication between camps and partners, and ensuring the safety of IDP camps during the conflict, 

c. Strive to meet the funding goals of the UNHCR as set by the Syrian Humanitarian Relief Program, Syrian Government Response Plan and the Syrian Regional Response Plan,

d. Meet on a monthly basis to carry out the mandate of this committee from November 2015 until November 2017,

e. Submit a quarterly report to the Secretary General and the United Nations Security Council on the recommendations made and reports published by the Working Group;

9. Further recommends that the United Nations Development Program (UNDP) and the Department of Peacekeeping Operations (DPKO) work alongside the International Rescue Committee (IRC) and the Department of Field Support on implementing a joint capacity-building program resembling the Framework for the Ten-Year Capacity Building Program between the United Nations and Syria to address the following issues:

a. Providing operational support to all field support missions by increasing transparency and efficiency regarding the distribution of humanitarian aid resources in the region and strengthen the building of internal civilian capacities,

b. Supports further training of aid workers and NGOs, via the United Nations Institute on Training and Research (UNITAR) on conflict scenarios and advise on protocols regarding working under dangerous conditions with respect to the United Nations Logistical Base and the Support Base which will provide consistent, quality and timely support for persons involved, 

c. Accelerate the pace of information-sharing related to internally displaced persons by working in conjunction with regional bodies and the Syrian government;

10. Welcomes member states and appropriate NGOs, to adhere to international humanitarian, human rights and refugee law;

11. Encourages member states to take all steps necessary to alleviate human suffering;

12. Decides to remain actively seized of the matter.
___________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Resolution 2

Resolution: UNSC/2015/2.0
Security Council of the United Nations
Sponsors: Russia, China, Czech Republic
Signatories: Syria, Iraq, Egypt, Turkey, Jordan, Lebanon, Italy, Germany

Reaffirming its primary responsibility for the maintenance of international peace and security, in accordance with the Charter of the United Nations, 

Reaffirming that terrorism in all forms and manifestations constitutes one of the most serious threats to international peace and security and that any acts of terrorism are criminal and unjustifiable regardless of their motivations, whenever and by whomsoever committed,

Reaffirming the need to combat by all means, in accordance with the Charter of the United Nations and international law, including applicable international human rights, refugee, and humanitarian law, threats to international peace and security caused by terrorist acts, stressing in this regard the important role the United Nations plays in leading and coordinating this effort,

Emphasizing that sanctions are an important tool under the Charter of the United Nations in the maintenance and restoration of international peace and security including countering terrorism, and underlining the importance of prompt and effective implementation of relevant resolutions, in particular Security Council resolutions 1267 (1999) and 1989 (2011) as key instruments in the fight against terrorism,

Recalling its Resolutions 1267 (1999), 1989 (2011), 2161 (2014), 2170 (2014), and 2178 (2014) and its Presidential Statements of 28 July 2014 and 19 November 2014, including its stated intention to consider additional measures to disrupt oil trade by Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant (ISIL, also known as Daesh), Al-Nusrah Front (ANF) and all other individuals, groups, undertakings and entities associated with Al-Qaida, as a source of terrorism financing,

Reaffirming also that terrorism cannot and should not be associated with any religion, nationality, or civilization,
Stressing that terrorism can only be defeated by a sustained and comprehensive approach involving the active participation and collaboration of all States, and international and regional organizations to impede, impair, isolate and incapacitate the terrorist threat, 

Reaffirming article 25 of the UN charter, under whose mandate member nations are bound to follow council decisions. 
  • Approves  the setting up of a cease-fire agreement brokered between the Syrian government and the various military groups stationed at Syrian Soil;
  • Have Resolved the setting up of UN body to conduct elections in the Syrian regime.
  • Emphasises the apeal for full allowance of UN peacekeeping forces and peace building commission after cessation of armed conflict for maintaining peace and security in the country;
  • Expresses its appreciation to the announcement of Syria being open for election under the able guidance of the UN body specially formulated for conducting the elections in Syria;
  • Urges  the international community to join hands against the extremist organizations such as ISIL, Jabhat Al-Nusra so as to protect the interests of the Middle Eastern nations with respect to territorial violations;
  • Demanding strongly the creation of a transitional government that can carry out the governance of the state of Syria under United Nations;
  • Urges removal of all sanctions against Syria after the elections are conducted in the Syrian regime;
  • Demands preserving Syrian state institutions including the army and the civil service, so that the elections can be conducted fairly and without any external interference;
  • Demands strongly the expansion of humanitarian aid to the IDP’s and the refugees to support the pressure on the machinery of neighbouring Middle Eastern countries;
  •  Requesting the Syrian refugees to take part in the voting process, withholding their discretion to return.

Explanation of draft resolution

The chairperson gave the delegates a briefing on the rules and regulations of drafting  a resolution.



France calls for a table debate

The delegates of the following countries were called for the table debate- US and France in block A, and Russia and Syria in block B.

Russia raised the following points-
That Russia does not want to see a US and French led coalition in Syria. The delegate of Russia further went on to support the Assad government by stating that the Syrian government is the only one truly fighting ISIS forces.
Russia was then questioned by the executive board on the situation in Ukraine, to which the delegate of Russia responded vaguely that the situation in Syria is different from that in Ukraine.


US raised the following points-
The delegate of USA stated that Russia supports those who violate human rights, and that protesting against a ruler does not make the people terrorists.
However they agreed with Russia with respect to ISIS and stated that they are in favour of fighting ISIS troops.


France raised the following points-
The delegate of France stated that NATO and EU won't budge until it is confirmed that no more violations will take place in Syria.

Syria raised the following points-
The delegate raised the point of the supply of weapons to Syrian civilians by the US n order to help them rebel the Assad government. They also proceeded to state that people needed to be controlled, to prevent violation of human rights.









The committee enters an unmoderated caucus

The delegate of France called for an unmoderated caucus for a duration of 10 minutes. The motion was passed with majority vote.
There were several discussions, with France raising points about ceasefire and Syria seeking US intervention. The delegate of US got a little too involved in the debate and lightheartedly stated that democracy should be eradicated.
Russia and Czech republic gave their ideas on forming a new and a more stable form of government.



Response to Russia

The delegate of USA felt that Russia branded people who raised their voice to bring forth the truth as rebels.
Germany stated that since the start of the Assad government, Syria has concurred a loss of $200 billion. This lead to 4 in every 5 Syrians being poverty stricken. The delegate also stated that the main cause of the crisis was the open firing of peaceful protests in March 2011, during which president Assad had stated that the open firing would not be halted.

This lead to the end of the moderated caucus.
  

Russia calls for a moderated caucus

Russia calls for a moderated caucus to discuss on the topic "Preventing another disaster and a change in the US led regime", for a total time of 20 minutes, with an individual speaker time of 120 sec. The motion was a tie, however the executive board decided to pass it considering it was the first motion raised by the Russian federation.

Russia raised the following points-
1.They demanded answers from superpower nations like the US for supporting the "rebels" over the      Syrian government.
2.They also did not want the US to set up its own government in Syria.




Italy

The delegate of Italy released the following points-
1. Italy will contribute 300 million pounds to the UN High Commission for refugees.
2. Italy will contribute 100 million pounds to Turkey to help it deal with the refugee crisis, since they have the largest number of refugees.
4. Italy supports the stand by USA and EU that Assad should step down immediately and a democratic election be held.

The moderated caucus

The delegate of France proposes to enter a moderated caucus for discussion on "Solutions to Syrian Crisis" for 15 minutes.
Delegate of France suggests a Geneva 3 conference and says wll allow ISIL delegate to appear in conference if they are ready to give up arms and discuss the solution under proper security and chooses to answer his view about ISIL to the EB in writing. While Russia claims that al conferences are pointless t which EB questions that just if a previous trial failed does it mean all the following attempts would be meaningless and failure.Kuwait pans to back the Syrian refugees, and states to donate 314 million.While Syria demands answer from UK to give a substantial docuement that Syrian government has done to "curbed Freedom of Press".

The comencement of GSL

China highlights the Syrian crisis reminding of the huge human resource loss since march 2011 when the war began and it supports providing humanitarian support.While France reminds the requirement of peace and puts forward issue of large intake of refugees by Europe supporting proposal of Turkey for a no fly zone in Syria. Syria comments on recommendation by China and is open to suggestions but believes that a no fly zone cannot exist because without air force it would be difficult to control the unrest in the country

The day 2 begins

The second day of the security council begins with voting for extension in the committee time which is followed by a roll call.

Working paper released by the committee

Supporters-Russia,China,Syria,Iraq,Germany,Turkey,Jordan,Lebanon.

1. To enter into  cease fire agreement between the military groups present in syria
2. To deploy UN peace keeping forces into Syria to ensure that there are no breaches conducted by any of the parties or the rebels
3.To respect the sovereignty of the Syria
4.The cease fire agreementto be followed and complied until the crisis comes to an end
5.Terms of cease fir agreement :-
  i)Cease fire to take place without dematerialzation of the army.
  ii)Syrian government to pick arms in case of breeches

The committee enters an unmoderated caucus

The outcome is a working paper proposing cease fire and stating the proper rules summarized within five points.

Update 2

Delegates the UNSC have just been informed that the NATO meeting in progress has been dissolved. The said NATO committee did not issue a press release. The committee could not reach a consensus on the actions to be taken against Russia.
Russian President Vladimir Putin has in another statement said –

“Russia is keeping a close tab on the current situation and would like to reiterate that we will not sit back and watch. I would like to put out a word to all NATO partners that any act of aggression by NATO members will be considered a declaration of war. As long as NATO members resolve to diplomatic negotiations Russia is also open to talks but an iron hand will be dealt with an iron hand”.

Delegate of France refuses explanations

The delegate of France refuses any explanation until delegates of Russia and China dodge the constant questions.
Delegate of germany proposes immediate cease fire which would not include withdrawal of troops.
Syria does not agree to the cease fire as the rebels may not comply with that and that may lead to unrest in the country. Russia wants US to step back and let the Syrian government take the decision, while Egypt suggests a joint operation by USA and Russia to fight ISIL.The delegate of Lebanon supports Egypt and claims that Syria can act if any of the groups do not comply to the cease fire.

Commencement of an unmoderated caucus

The committee enters an unmoderated caucus to discuss the probable solutions.
Delegate of Iraq proposes to cease fire in the area which Syria does not agree due to the insecurity  of Syrian troops.

Further discussion in the moderated caucus

Delegate of New Zealand proposes an immediate cease fire and leaves the committee.
Delegate of China states that intervention by some "western countries" would only impede efforts to find a solution to find a solution and would inflame already volatile situation there, and demanded a political solution and no outside military intervention in Syria
Russia questions if the dplomatic talks are going to be a solution and demands USA to stop interfering .

Proposed solution by delegate of Germany

"The Assad government should back down, from its power and let a democratic govenment be established in Syria and order to handle the power gap, the UN interfere in order to establish peace until a democratic government be established in Syria and it order to attain this we believe that NATO, America and Russia back out from Syrian Soil."

Moderated caucus

France raises the motion "Temporary Solutions to the problem".
Russia states that they support the Russians on a humanitarian ground and are here to find solutions, where France demands reports on what Russia has done for Syrian civilians.
New Zealand reminds the committee of the serious situation and requests for more fruitful discussions.
Syria states that this war situation is utterly due to USA interventions
Germany proposes an immediate solution for handling refugees.